It seems like Liverpool.com has gone the way of so much print media, following a statement on Twitter that the mag ‘as you know it is no more’ and a tip that most of its editorial staff have been made redundant.
This is a shame – most obviously for the journalists involved, who have my sympathy – as it was a good effort in a genre that’s frequently utterly useless, but the news is not especially surprising.
Trinity Mirror has struggled to make a success out of two (or is it three?) culture/listings/lifestyle/entertainment magazines during my tenure in the city, with the ill-fated Bigmouth lasting less time than Liverpool.com, as I recall (though Liverpool.com, as the title suggests, was tilted towards an online presence).
I’d guess that the reason behind the fate that befell these two mags is the same that the glut of similar independent magazines like Black+White, that sprung up in the city in the early 2000s, struggled to last more than a couple of years – the market simply couldn’t sustain them. Well, that and the fact that most of them were terrible.
I worked in print for most of my early career and watched ad spend fall off a cliff after 9/11, although it was obviously in decline before that day.There’s a similar situation developing in online advertising now, and with revenues from both print and online likely to be down, media companies are having a hard time.
And while the build-up to 2008 in Liverpool might have made such ventures viable, I’m guessing it’s increasingly hard.
I suspect Liverpool.com will be Trinity Mirror’s last attempt at a print magazine, though some kind of online presence is surely workable, and necessary – and the Twitter statement seems to leave the door open for a new venture.
As Liverpool Echo editor Alastair Machray noted on the magazine’s launch:
“I was flabbergasted, when we began putting the site and the mag together, by the sheer volume of leisure options that are out there. The only thing missing was Liverpool.com itself.”
Another cautionary tale about Twitter, and about April Fool’s Day – this one concerns Tommy Scott, the bloke who was in Space, and an internet rumour that he had died.
Not exactly the height of sophistication, and not remotely funny, and that’s before you factor the news somehow filtering back to Scott’s mother.
I noticed this news circulating around Twitter’s Liverpool fraternity last night and though it a bit odd.
An official press release from his record company Antipop had said: “We are sorry for the untimely death of one of our great sons” and detailed that he died of heart failure.
It didn’t surprise me an hour or so later to see that it was, in fact, a hoax.
Why exactly anyone though this funny in the first place is a bit baffling, but if you release something like this it will take on a life of its own.
And surely the whole idea of an April Fool’s Day joke is that it’s patently absurd, but hopefully a tiny bit believable.
Since the Scott prank is not remotely funny and quite believable it’d doubly pointless.
The Echo described Liverpool’s music fraternity as ‘united in grief, which quickly turned to anger’, though I suppose you could add ‘when we phoned them up for a quote and told them about it,’ if you were a cynic.
Still, it goes to show the power of social media. It’s fairly obvious that someone at Scott’s current label dreamed up the hoax, perhaps as a bit of cheap publicity, or perhaps as a rather naive prank.
In time gone by a stunt like this would have quickly died or been exposeed as untrue before it got to a wider audience. But in the age of the internet even small mistakes are exposed and can spread like wildfire, as the person behind ‘Cisco fatty’ found to her cost.
The Cisco Fatty lost a job, the idea of Tommy Scott’s mother weeping at the fictional loss of her son exposes the terribly cruel consequences of a simple-minded stunt that the amplifying power of the internet can have.
I’m not going to get in the detail of the Hillsborough disaster, which is nearing its 20th anniversary in April.
I was 11 at the time and don’t remember a lot about it, aside from finding the names of the roads and ends associated with the tragedy disturbingly memorable. Liverpool Guild of Students, of which I was a member, had a memorial on the wall as a tribute to a student lost on that day.
I do not and cannot really relate to the way Hillsborough affected Liverpool, so I have no right to intrude on, or share in, that grief. That emotion is obvious every day when another stack of Sun newspapers goes unsold in Liverpool.
I was playing cricket last year when I expressed surprise that someone had brought along a copy of the Sun, and subsequently spent some time explaining why to some Liverpool lads. They were as shocked by the story as I was by the fact that they didn’t already know.
All of which brings me onto the role of the Sun and more specifically, Kelvin Mackenzie. I’m not going to repeat what was published, but it can be easily found on a search engine.
The Sun attempted to win round Liverpool in a charm offensive in 2004 under the editorship of Rebekah Wade. It was largely in vain and people are free to make what they will of the motivations of the Sun and News International.
It would be remiss to pretend that the Sun printed the only questionable coverage too. The Daily Mirror and The Star were also at fault.
Mackenzie, editor of the Sun at the time and darling of Rupert Murdoch, did apologise in the early 90’s, but later rescinded his apology.
To this day Mackenzie maintains that everything The Sun printed was ‘the truth’ – a reference to the notorious lies printed in The Sun on 19 April 1989.
He actually laid out the front page himself, and the full fascinating story is laid out in John Pilger‘s book Hidden Agendas, which Liverpool Gazette actually serialised when I was editor.
I’ve taken some quotes here from Hidden Agendas. There’s a PDF of the relevant chapter, A Cultural Chernobyl, here. It’s worth reading for anyone who doesn’t know the background.
‘THE TRUTH’ was the opposite. Like much in MacKenzie’s Sun, it was clearly intended to pander to prejudice. Other journalists on the Sun appeared to know this instinctively.
“As MacKenzie’s layout was seen by more and more people,” wrote Peter Chippendale and Chris Horrie in their history of the Sun, “a collective shudder ran through the office [but] MacKenzie’s dominance was so total there was nobody left in the organisation who could rein him in except Murdoch.
“[Everyone] seemed paralysed, ‘looking like rabbits in the headlights’, as one hack described them. The error staring them in the face was too glaring ? It obviously wasn’ta silly mistake; nor was it a simple oversight.
“Nobody really had any comment on it – they just took one look and went away shaking their heads in wonder at the enormity of it ? It was a ‘classic smear’.”
Pilger goes on to detail the aftermath:
In the days that followed the tragedy, Billy Butler, a popular Radio Merseyside disc jockey, became a voice for Liverpool’s grief and anger. “There were newsagents calling in,” he told me, “assuring people they would not stock the Sun.
“They were writing on their windows, ‘We do not have the Sun here’. There was a public burning of the Sun in Kirkby. Caller after caller said they were boycotting the paper, and the boycott is still going on today. It’s a marvellous way that ordinary people have to show their power, and this city used it.”
…sales of the Sun on Merseyside were falling fast, down by almost 40 per cent, a loss that would cost News International an estimated £10 million a year.
When the Press Council subsequently condemned the Sun’s lies, and the boycott intensified, Murdoch ordered MacKenzie to respond publicly. BBC Radio 4’s The World This Weekend was chosen as his platform. The ‘sarf London’ accent that was integral to MacKenzie’s persona as an ‘ordinary punter’ was now a contrite middle-class voice that fitted Radio 4.
‘It was my decision’, said MacKenzie, ‘and my decision alone to do that front page in that way, and I made a rather serious error.’
In 1996 MacKenzie was back on Radio 4, this time in a very different mood. “The Sun did not accuse anybody of anything,” he said aggressively. “We were the vehicle for others.”
MacKenzie has since made several statements indicating that he has nothing to regret about the Sun’s coverage. He’s since been employed on and off by the Sun and the BBC, resulting in this memorable protest in 2007:
Whether people continue to buy the Sun or is up to them, and I suspect News International and the current editorial team have largely given up on ever breaking back into the city, but I’m personally glad that Liverpool continues to shun it.
Not only should they continue to do so until MacKenzie offers a fulsome apology, they should to do so to send an important signal to news media that smear journalism against honest, decent people has repercussions.
But above all, it’s important to remember why.
• There’s an interview with Jimmy McGovern on Black+White which touches on Hillsborough and the resulting TV drama.
It’s no wonder the Tories have been keeping their mouths shut over the last couple of years, when the likes of Conservative Shadow Home Secretary Chris Grayling can propose Manchester United and England defender Gary Neville as a good role model for Liverpool youngsters.
It’s such a mind-bogglingly strange thing to say, even before you factor in the fact that Neville plays for the most hated football club in the country, and the fact that there is probably no-one more hated by Reds and people in Liverpool generally. Here’s why:
“I can’t stand Liverpool, I can’t stand Liverpool people, I can’t stand anything to do with them.”
Grayling went on to admit that he shouldn’t have said Gary Neville, he meant to say Ryan Giggs instead. Liverpool fans are unimpressed.
Apparently Grayling had been out and about on the mean streets of Toxteth, where I lived for some time, and was struck by the lack of male role models.
This is probably a reasonable point, but short of Gary Neville turning up and fostering some of these kids, ploughing a few hundred grand into the Florrie and becoming some sort of latter-day Pied Piper, I don’t see how he could much help.
David Cameron has apparently dispatched the hapless Grayling, who doubles as ‘shadow minister for Merseyside’, to Liverpool to cultivate Tory voters – all three of them – in the region. Let’s remind ourselves why people in Liverpool, and the North more widely, don’t tend to vote Tory.
You could choose the wholesale dismantling of the manufacturing industry. Perhaps the war on unions. Maybe the sale of council houses that has left traditionally close-knit communities at the mercy of profiteering slum landlords.
All of these factors have left places like Toxteth shattered, with few meaningful jobs available, drug-use rife and community spirit broken by transitory occupancy.
‘There’s no such thing as society’, was the 80s’ lasting socio-economic legacy. Well, now there isn’t it’s a bit rich to visit places like Liverpool bemoaning that fact.