Reflecting on Liverpool’s Capital of Culture Transition night finale

A video I took last night on my tinny mobile phone of the fireworks at Pierhead.

Thanks to some idiotic regulations in force at the Albert Dock we were faced with the choice of watching betweeen a gap in the Pumphouse and Dock buildings or walking around the entire Dock, by which time they would have certainly been finished. Lunacy.

Anyway, later on I went to the Tate to see the diverting but fairly hollow Fifth Floor and intriguing William Blake exhibition; and the Bluecoat where the decidedly patchy Next Up Liverpool Art Now exhbition and at least two gigs were on.

Tate Fifth Floor

Bluecoat Next Up

Me and the missus got told off for taking for trying to take a picture of me with my arm round a owl-faced child. The absurdity of that admission is not lost on me, but touches on a particularly irritating fact about certain galleries that maintain a strict policy on installation art that’s totally at odds with the aims of making art more accessible and less daunting for people. So I carried on taking photos regardless, just to be contrary.

The night ended off in the Baltic with several pints of Smoked Porter with a group of friends, and much talk of ‘cranking’, which is best left unexplained.

It was boozy, musical, cultural and fun and it seemed fitting.

Ringo Starr: A life in adverts

Ringo Starr

I’ve been pondering Ringo Starr’s latest advert, in which he suggests that all of his fame and fortune are down to him changing his name from Richard Starkey to Ringo Starr – rather than the songwriting genius of John Lennon, Paul McCartney and George Harrison.


Perhaps it’s unfair to have a pop at the the Scouse drummer. He’s been the butt of jokes about his rubbish drumming for donkey’s years, regardless of the fact that he’s actually an excellent drummer and we have his appearances in the likes of That’ll be the Day to prove that he had more than one string to his bow.

And could Thomas the Tank Engine ever be as enjoyable with Ringo’s ‘Is-he-drunk?’ Liverpudlian drawl.


It’s become rather fashionable and easy to knock Ringo over the course of the last year, what with his feeble Liverpool 08 single, ridiculing (not unfairly) the idea that he’d return to live in Liverpool and his bizarre Youtube appearance to demand that no more fanmail should be sent to him because he was too busy to sign any more Beatles crap.


A quick search on the net reveals exactly what Ringo is busy doing: earning cash from anyone who’s willing to throw it at him.

What the following adverts prove is that Ringo was, once upon a time, the funniest and coolest Beatle, who wasn’t bothered about sending himself up. In the light of Ringo’s disasters in 2008, I prefer to remember him like this.













Should we save Jaguar Land Rover?

Jaguar

Although this entry doesn’t really revolve around culture, or arguably Liverpool I though I’d jot off a few words about the continuing Jaguar Land Rover situation as the city’s papers (indeed several Trinity Mirror titles, who can spot a trend when they see one) have really gone for broke in their support of the company, now owned by India’s Tata Motors but with a factory in Halewood.

 

Like anyone suddenly confronted with the mainstream media’s take on a subject they’re fairly well-versed in, I’ve been somewhat bemused and irritated by some of the uninformed, crass and plain bizarre opinions I’ve read in papers and on the web, not that the regional newspapers who have been campaigning on the issue have got much wrong.

There’s a cornucopia of ill-informed comments after Robert Peston’s blog that are indicative of how keen people are to shoot their mouths off about things they know nothing about.

So, I thought I’d put the record straight as I see it because, well because this is my blog and I can.

Although I’ve read a lot about JLR being ‘troubled’, I don’t really think that’s the case. Since it was sold by Ford to Tata last year for a fairly pitiful £1.15bn, Jag has brought out the fantastic sports saloon XF, is in the process of quietly retiring the underwhelming X-Type, revamped the XK coupe and roadster and has a revamped XJ in the pipeline.

As a result of this strong product line-up, the Big Cat was one of the very few manufacturers to actually increase sales in the UK last year.

Land Rover, which has admittedly seen sales plummet by around 50 per cent in the UK over 2008, has the Freelander, Discovery, Range Rover and Rangey Sport and the hybrid LRX to come. Frankly, all of Land Rover’s models are the best in class. The company has a formidable line-up of models and is making significant strides towards greening its products.

The trouble that JLR appears to be in seems to be down to parent-company Tata’s unwillingness to commit cash to its prize acquisition.

Black Swan

Like most manufacturers, Jaguar Land Rover has been caught out by a Perfect Storm (or Black Swan event if you prefer your metaphors more melodramatic) of rising fuel prices, environmental and political pressure to reduce CO2 emissions, wildly fluctuating exchange rates and, of course, what’s being called the worst economic crisis since the ’30s. As a premium manufacturer JLR is right at the sharp end of the car industry’s woes.

As a result JLR is widely thought to be seeking around £1bn from the British government, on top of an injection of around £600m from parent company Tata. Some commentators have suggested that such a significant injection of cash amounts to a de facto nationalisation of the company, as that’s not far off the asking price Tata paid for JLR twelve months ago, since when the value of the company has likely tumbled. Some have even advocated this idea. (Curiously Wales Online has chosen not to publish my comment explaining why this won’t happen.)

I don’t think there’s much likelihood of the government not providing what JLR insists is purely and squarely a loan (you can read a fairly vague but likely indication in one of Mandelson’s boring speeches here), although there are likely to be some stiff conditions to prevent other manufacturers going cap-in-hand to business secretary Peter Mandelson.

I don’t have a lot of time for Mandelson, he was without doubt the most unpleasant man I ever interviewed, and I found his re-re-entry in the government astonishing given his record – but he’s no chump.

Mandy will stump up the cash for JLR, but there are some important questions to be asked first regarding why a multi-media conglomerate like Tata can’t find any cash to plough into its most recent significant acquisition, especially at a time when Tata has decided that the time is right to enter Formula One as a sponsor, a notorious money pit for manufacturers.

Lessons from MG Rover

Unlike 2005, when the government allowed MG Rover to go under in a set of circumstances that can only be described as murky, the government has woken up to the reality than JLR is one of the few remaining bastions of British manufacturing and design ingenuity and vital R&D – and therefore worth preserving.

The fallout of Rover’s collapse continues to pose problems in the West Midlands relating to its former staff – most of whom are highly-skilled – and their search for skilled employment. And it should be remembered that when a car manufacturer goes bust it takes out a whole supply chain and raft of dealerships too.

In the current economic conditions the government has often chosen to intervene in such situations; saving jobs, skills and taxes, so I don’t believe a fate similar to Rover’s is likely to befall JLR.

Nor do I think the government has any intention of taking control of JLR. Seeing Jag and Landie through the 12-18 months should make economic sense. The government gets its money back and JLR’s product line-up starts to sell strongly on a global scale. At that point, assuming the global economy has picked up, Tata will need to plough billions into JLR in order to maintain the company’s competitive advantage. The government should get in as quickly as possible, and get out again as soon as conditions allow.

Why we should not bail out JLR

So we’re all agreed – the government saves two British institutions and everyone’s happy. Even the Tories have absurdly tried to align themselves with the public mood, despite vociferously decrying the government’s decision to save Northern Rock and Bradford & Bingley.

But if Ford could not make a success of Jaguar over the last 20 years and after investing billions of dollars, runs a popular argument, how can Tata make anything of it?

And haven’t we been through all of this before, with BMC and British Leyland? The short answer is no –
the circumstances behind this crisis are a world apart and if the government stumps up the cash it won’t get its hands dirty.

Another train of thought goes that the government will set a precedent of bailing out struggling firms if it provides the cash for JLR, a concern Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg has voiced. While that may be true, a loan for JLR is very different from bailing out Woolies, for example.

Without putting too fine a point on it JLR has a strong product and its workforce highly-skilled on a global level, while the decline of the UK’s car industry would likely be a final nail in the coffin for British manufacturing and a big blow to R&D work in the UK. JLR says it spends £400m on R&D annually.

The third objection I’ve seen is that instead of a loan for JLR the UK should plough money into green technology, a pretty woolly argument that ignores the fact that car manufacturers are best-placed to develop such technology and already spend billions on R&D in this area. Throw the car-makers on the scrap-heap and you wave goodbye to all of that shared and concentrated knowledge.

The JLR loan does have its pitfalls: an extended recession will see off a good many otherwise-healthy manufacturers. Fiat boss Sergio Marchionne recently predicted a massively-consolidated and contracted car industry in the hands on half a dozen mega-companies within five years’ time – and high-end manufacturers are likely to feel the pinch most. If that happens JLR may struggle, government loans or not.

Further, there’s absolutely nothing to prevent Tata shifting production to India, even after a £1bn government loan. Indeed, the threat may be implicit that if Mandelson does not stump up the cash Tata will simply asset-strip the company and lay off all workers.

Lastly, the rest of the UK’s car industry will be watching closely. If parent-company GM, itself receiving billions from the US government in a last-gasp bailout, goes under UK manufacturer Vauxhall will be left with no choice but to go cap-in-hand to Mandelson. Add in Volkswagen-owned Bentley, BMW-owned Rolls-Royce and Mini, Proton-owned Lotus and privately-owned Aston Martin as ‘British’ brands and the JLR precedent may start to look worrying.

All of that ignores the fact that Toyota, Nissan and Honda all design and build cars in the UK too. If Indian-owned JLR, US-owned Vauxhall, German-owned Bentley, Rolls and Mini, Malaysian-owned Lotus and Middle-Eastern sheik-owned Aston get cash, why not them?

It’s a tricky conundrum that’s based on the supposed British-ness of foreign-owned manufacturers, despite the fact that the likes of Vauxhall hasn’t been in British hands for nearly 100 years and the likes of the Toyota Avensis is British-designed and British-built.

But more than that it begs again the question as to exactly why Tata is unable to find the money itself. Might the Indian conglomerate simply to prefer to use government-backed loans at cheaper rates than hard-to-come-by commercial loans from banks?

Why we should bail out JLR

There’s no meaningful catch-all answer to those questions, and Mandelson must know it. But he must also know that, despite the potential ramifications, he must not allow JLR to go to the wall. The feelgood factor of saving a company that a suddenly-nostalgic public is swinging behind will make for a rare ray of light amid the financial gloom. Not to mention key constituencies in the Midlands that Labour will need to win at the next election.

But most of all, stripped of the hysteria, the headline-grabbing campaigns and the false nostalgia is the fact that saving JLR makes good financial sense. For the devastation a ravaged manufacturing base can bring Mandelson must only look to the Welsh Valleys, Midlands, North-East or Scotland – or Detroit for that matter.

The company made a sizeable £300m operating profit as recently as the first two quarters of 2008, has a strong and desirable model range and some of the best automotive minds in the world at its disposal. Land Rover has largely been in profit for some years, though Ford never released actual figures.

Jag has not, due to the FoMoCo’s woeful mismanagement of the brand in an attempt to make successful synergies from its various brands. The results were the naffly-retro S-Type and Mondeo-based X-Type, the latter of which made a mockery of Jag’s supposedly upmarket image. With both of those models going or gone, the symbol of a resurgent Jag is the XF, which was won industry plaudits and sold strongly.

Partly as a result combined UK JLR sales in 2008 were higher than those of volume manufacturers Hyundai, Kia, Mazda, Mini, Seat and Skoda and comfortably ahead of executive/sports/luxury manufacturers Alfa Romeo, Aston Martin, Bentley, Cadillac, Jeep, Lexus, Porsche, Rolls-Royce and Saab combined, according to figures from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT).

The bottom line is that, before the credit crunch, JLR was a viable business and the likelihood is that it will be again – assuming the company make it through the next 12-18 months of economic turmoil.

With Tata unable, or possibly unwilling, to seek funds elsewhere to plough into JLR whether it does is down to Peter Mandelson. Where the Labour government once stood back as a British manufacturer went bust it must now intervene, despite the risks.

• While more cynical commentators than me may question the motives behind various media campaigns, there’s a Facebook group on saving JLR and a Downing Street petition.

Capital of Culture finale – Liverpool’s Transition Light Night

If anyone’s waiting on my exceptionally boring and lengthy treatise on Liverpool’s Capital of Culture year you need to wait a few days longer, if that’s possible.

Until then here’s a reminder of the very last event of Liverpool’s Captial of Culture year – the hand-over to Vilnius/Linz comprising a wide array of cultural events and spectacles this coming Saturday (10 January 2009).

The not-actually-finished Pierhead hosts the kick-off, projecting a video onto the not-quite-finished Museum of Liverpool and a lantern parade to launch the extended Leeds-Liverpool canal link.

Following on from that is the Light Night, with the city’s cultural destination throwing their doors open til late. Make the most of it – that’s your lot!

In the meantime check out the blog’s Capital of Culture round-up of the year.

Press release from Liverpool City Council follows:

Liverpool is to say a special thank-you for everyone’s support throughout its year as the UK’s European Capital of Culture 2008.

Cultural venues across the city centre are throwing open their doors late into the evening as part of a special Transition Light Night, in what will be one of the biggest free events in the Capital of Culture programme.

The cultural extravaganza on Saturday, 10th January 2009 – a year to the day the city officially launched its culture year – marks Liverpool’s transition from ’08 to its Year of the Environment.

The evening will kick-off with a spectacular ‘People’s Celebration’ along the Mersey waterfront and new-look Pier Head.

This free waterfront party will be a multi-media sound and light spectacle – the first event on the iconic World Heritage site since the extensive £100 million pound regeneration of the Pier Head public space.

Starting from 6.15pm, the celebration will include a filmic review of ’08 that uses the recently-clad, £70m Museum of Liverpool’s gigantic waterfront window as a 27 ft by 80ft cinema screen.  There will also be screens at the New Mersey Ferry terminal and at the ECHO Arena Liverpool on Kings Dock.

The event will involve artistic interludes such as a lantern installation of the new Leeds-Liverpool canal link, an arts and crafts market along the piazza at Mann Island and drum and dance performances.

There will also be ceremonial handovers to the cities of Linz and Vilnius, the European Capital’s of Culture ’09, and to representatives from London 2012 to mark the launch of Britain’s Cultural Olympiad, as well as a mass sing along of the anthemic ‘All Together Now’. The show concludes with a pyrotechnic finale fired from ships on the river.

The 7pm finale signals the start of Liverpool’s Transition Light Night with many of the city’s world renowned cultural facilities offering visitors and residents a unique and largely free late night experience.

The Merseyside Maritime Museum, Tate Liverpool, the Bluecoat, Open Eye, FACT, Liverpool Biennial, the Contemporary Urban Centre and The Flying Picket will all be open, and the city centre’s high quality range of restaurants, bars and clubs will be geared up and ready to receive the huge numbers expected in the city on this significant night.

Especially commissioned street theatre, music and dance performances will bring an extra buzz of excitement to the city’s public spaces, pedestrian and shopping zones.

• Venues participating in Liverpool ‘s  Transition Light Night (all events free unless otherwise stated): 

Tate Liverpool – The Fifth Floor: Ideas taking space – open all day until 10pm.

Merseyside Maritime Museum and International Slavery Museum – open through the day and closes at 10pm.

The Beatles Story – Special 2 for 1 offer. Last admission 8.30pm, open until 10pm.

Open Eye Gallery – David Goldblatt; Intersections Intersected – all day to 10pm.

The Bluecoat – Galleries open to 10pm, the building till 10.30pm.

FACT open until 11pm – DING>>D0NG: open until 9pm

Wolstenholme Projects – After the Curtain Falls exhibition – 7pm – 10.30pm

3345 Parr Street – Terry Cryer Exhibition – Open until 2am

The new Picket – FUSED – tomorrow’s people! 7pm – 10.30pm. 14+ gig

Leaf – Leaf Unplugged 7.30pm till late.

Contemporary Urban Centre – Family fun day – 11am-6pm. Music night from 7-11pm.