Mersey Ferry building wins an award – for being awful

I’m feeling a little vindicated in my view that the new Merseytravel ferry terminal and Beatles Story outlet is badly situated and unsympathetic to its surroundings.

Others have been more forceful in their views, and now the building has won the Carbuncle Cup, an architecture magazine’s award for the worst new building. Incidentally, One Park West – a building I think may be worse – was also nominated.

The ferry building is described as ‘a shining example of bad architecture and bad planning’ on the Building Design website. As I’ve said before, what constitutes bad architecture is open to debate and not something I’m qualified to judge.

But it should have been clear all along that the siting of the building as it has appeared was problematic at best: in front of the three graces and slap bang in the middle of a UNESCO World Fricking Heritage site.

Anyway, for the record, here’s what some of yer actual architects think:

“The winner is the building that shows how bad architecture and bad planning can combine to produce something truly awful — a building so ugly it can turn human flesh to stone or at the very least make grown men cry.”

“…in thrall to some horribly misconceived idea of the avant–garde.”

“It is such an amazing site, directly in front of the Three Graces, but the architects seem barely to have noticed. It is like letting a bad second-year student build next to St Peter’s.”

“This is bad patronage by an ignorant council which thinks having jazzy architecture is putting the city on the map again.”

And there you have it. Another finger levelled at the council, or at least the collection of QUANGOs, lobby groups and other interests that seem to have a hand in deciding what gets built and where in the city. Once again, Liverpool looks like a basket case thanks to its leaders.

I’ll leave the last word to Building Design:

“When you go there you think: oh no, I can’t believe they’ve done that.”

Quite.

Calling Liverpool artists – design the new Top Shop/Top Man store

Any passing readers who happen to be artists (there are regular readers, right?) might be interested to know that the Liverpool branch of Top Man/Shop is offering the opportunity to decorate one of their walls.

Not on an ad hoc basis, you understand, but as part of some competition to win some vouchers. It’s a bloody big wall, so it might be fun if you’re into that sort of thing, but my holiday last week has meant that the deadline is pretty close – 3rd September (a week today).

More details here: Top Man blog.

Abandon all Hope – another fucking Tesco

You know, Tesco isn’t all bad. Well, OK it is – but a new Tesco store isn’t the end of the world.

 However, a new Tesco store on Hope Street – slap bang in the middle of the ‘cultural quarter’, connecting two astonishing cathedrals, host to the iconic Philharmonic Hall, Everyman Theatre and Philharmonic pub and blessed with its own street festival – is a bloody awful prospect.

Announced at a time when the city council has somehow, disgracefully, allowed a developer to destroy Josephine Butler House with the promise of a car park, the prospect of another sodding Tesco store blighting the otherwise-charming thoroughfare is a depressing one.

Tesco in Liverpool

I think there’s an important caveat to this discussion though. Tesco isn’t ‘evil’, as Liberal Democrat Berni Turner says, and I don’t think such contributions are helpful.

There’s certainly questions to be asked in terms of Tesco’s attitudes towards its suppliers and, like any megalithic international organisation I’m sure there are question marks over its social and environmental records.

But this debate should focus purely and squarely on the prospect of one of its gaudy stores, and accompanying footfall and congestion, destroying the character of one of the city’s more pleasant and historic streets.

In that context I don’t know why this is even being debated – is there anyone in the entire city who would vote for such a blot on the landscape? And what of the colossal over-supply and impact on other retailers in the area?

For the record Tesco wants to build one of its Express outlets in the building that was formerly Roadkill, just along for the Philharmonic pub. It would be, by my reckoning, the ninth in the city centre alone after the new Old Hall Street store opened recently.

Normally residents associations would step in and tell Tesco where to shove it, but I fear the transitory nature of the residents – including plenty of students – is likely to mean a lack of dedicated opposition in the area.

And I don’t see how the council has the power to stop the store opening, as it falls within the proscribed use of the building. At best there can be some horse trading over what the store looks like.

Maybe some form of protest may give cause to Sir Terry Leahy – son of Liverpool, Tesco head honcho and Liverpool Vision board member – cause to step in.

It’s the only way I think we can avoid the prospect of yet another fucking Tesco opening up in the city centre.

• Join the Facebook group

• Image by Sam the Sham via Creative Commons

Crucial playlists: Bunnymen, Wah! and Teardrop Explodes

On a particular online message board I frequent, author, journalist and pop-culture know-it-all Keith Topping holds forth on all matters pertaining to footy, cricket, music, Hammer horrors, TV and curries. Keith’s knowledge of music, film and TV is encyclopedic, but coupled to a obvious love, or sometimes loathing, of the subject matter.

The subject of essential playlists for punk and new wave bands recently cropped up, with some serious muso knowledge being thrown about. Keith knows his shit, so he allowed me to reproduce them here. I dare any Liverpool music types to attempt to better them.

Sadly, my brilliant idea to replicate the playlists on Spotify hit a hurdle with Wylie. The music jukebox has a few blank patches going back over the years, rather like…well you can probably see where I was going with that.

But, there’s Bunnymen and Teardrop Explodes playlists to listen to, and if you’re of a mind to you can fit them on a CD. Until Spotify catches up with Liverpool’s three wise men, here’s the playlists.

Crucial playlists

Liverpool, 1977. The Clash are in town and Eric’s is bursting at the seams. Mathew Street hasn’t seen a day like this since John, Paul, George and Pete were down in the best of cellars. In the smoke-filled, speed-fueled leather-bodied crush, Cope bumps into Wylie whilst Mac, a vision in studied cool, looks on. Tonite. Of all nights. There’s gonna be a fight. But, instead, there’s a band, The Crucial Three.

Who last six weeks, play no gigs, write about six songs and yet will go on become one of the most influential of the coming decade. Egos clash like the angular chords they play. Schisms develop. Separate ways. The Nova Mob, begat A Shallow Madness and thence become The Teardrop Explodes – Pere Ubu meets The Monkees up Syd Barrett’s back passage.

‘It’s just like sleeping gas, it’s so ethereal’, ‘… now I’m a bouncing bomb,’ ‘I’ve been livin’ through changes…’ Copey trailblazes leaving all but Gary and Balfe in his wakes. Why are The Teardrop Explodes different from a cow? Cos a cow has horns at the front and a **** at the back. Things get Wilder. Then America and drugs kill the sound and Cope goes under his turtle-shell to a solo bridal path that’s still being trod today.

Mac finds the Sergeant and a drum machine before Les and Peter come on board. They’ve been in a daze for days. Doors influences and Apocalypse Now stage sets. Bill Drummond says ‘do it clean, d’you know what I mean?’ Videos in iceland before U2 made such a thing uncool as ****.

Then the shimmering orchestral wonders of Ocean Rain and its anthemic attendant singles before egos get in the way again and a long wilderness follows. But nothing ever last forever, especially not wildernesses, and then comes a time where ever Bunny must have his day again.

Wylie can’t keep bandmates either, and goes through more name-changes than the Spizzles. Heat! Shambeko! Mighty! Always Wah. Naff Poo, the art of bluff and scallywag shenanigans as otherboys get the message. ‘D’you think that you could keep the secret long?’ Then, thanks to Peel and Jensen, the Spector wall-of-sound-like Story of the Blues hits bigger than anything Copey and Mac can dream of. But following it up, that’s another matter – despite the joys of Hope.

Different paths, but each with the same singular vision. Scally shamen. Voices of a broken generation. Pool cool. Dey do do, don’t dey doh? Long ago and far away – waiting for the Crucial Three, wondering that went wrong.

I’ve Been In a Daze For Days – The Essential Echo & the Bunnymen

Villiers Terrance (2:44)

The Cutter (3:56)

Never Stop (3:31)

Stars Are Stars (2:45)

A Promise (4:08)

Ocean Rain (5:12)

All That Jazz (2:47)

Rescue (4:26)

Crystal Days (2:26)

Lips Like Sugar (4:52)

The Back of Love (3:14)

Heads Will Roll (3:33)

Thorn of Crowns (4:52)

Do It Clean (2:44)

The Puppet (3:07)

Nothing Lasts Forever (3:57)

Silver (3:22)

The Killing Moon (5:50)

Seven Seas (3:20)

Bring on the Dancing Horses (3:56)

Over the Wall (5:59)

Total: 1:19:41

• Listen to the Essential Echo & The Bunnymen on Spotify.

Why’d You Have To Make It So Hard? – The Essential Pete Wylie & The Mighty Wah!

The Wind Up (4:57)

Remember (3:05)

Hope (I Wish You’d Believe Me) (6:36)

Sinful (4:09)

Seven Minutes to Midnight – single version (3:43)

Sleep (A Lullaby for Josie) (4:30)

Long Tall Scally (The Ballad Thereof) (4:24)

I Know There was Something – Maverick Years version (7:54)

Otherboys (3:59)

Don’t Step on the Cracks (3:09)

Yuh Learn – Peel Session version (6:50)

You Can’t Put Your Arms Around a Memory (1:18)

Shambeko (3:57)

Better Scream (3:17)

Year of Decision (2:57)

The Death of Wah! (5:51)

Come Back (The Story of the Reds (4:24)

The Story of the Blues (Pt. 1) (4:00)

Total 1:19:00

Waiting For The Crucial Three, Wondering What Went Wrong – The Essential Teardrop Explodes

Second Head (3:11)

Seven Views of Jerusalem (3:47)

Passionate Friend (3:29)

The In-Psychlopaedia (4:01)

Poppies (5:04)

Serious Danger (3:32)

Christ Versus Warhol (3:54)

Treason (It’s Just a Story) (2:57)

Like Leila Khaled Said (3:48)

Nobody Knows This Is Everywhere (4:04)

Suffocate (3:47)

Reward (2:42)

The Culture Bunker (5:29)

The Great Dominions (4:34)

Use Me (5:49)

When I Dream – long version (5:46)

Thief of Baghdad (3:09)

Sleeping Gas – Live at Club Zoo (9:27)

Total 1:19:21

• Listen to the Essential Teardrop Explodes on Spotify.